Grim's Toy Show Wikia
Register

Jay Evans (FKA Jay Dempsey/Ice Demon, Real Name Jayson Anthony Calnan) is an American professional wrestler, who wrestles for GTS Wrestling. Evans has held the GTS YouTube Wrestling Figures Heavyweight Championship, GTS Championship, GTS Intercontinental Championship, GTS United States Championship and GTS Hardcore Championship. He is also a GTS Triple Crown Champion and GTS Grand Slam Champion.


GTS

Jay Dempsey was first introduced as a referee and a part of DF. After feeling he wasn't getting enough opportunities, he turned on DF, becoming the Ice Demon (a parody of Finn Balor's 'Demon' gimmick).

Dempsey went on to beat Lance Scaper for the GTS Title and held it for 34 days until Tommy Salami cashed in his Food In the Fridge contract during a triple threat match for the belt and won it. By then he was out of the GTS title picture but will go on to beat Jimmy Controversy for the GTS Intercontinental Championship and held it for 17 days until he lost the belt to Grim but regained it five days later by dressing up as Pimp Cara. Dempsey would go on to hold it for 21 days until he lost it to Pita Kid. He then ditched the 'Ice Demon' gimmick and change his name to 'Jay 'The Key' Evans' (in which he carries a key balloon to the ring, and often puts it around his waist). He will go on to win 4 Hardcore Championships and join a group called the King's Keys to Chaos. He also has victories over Grim and Robbie E. On April 17, Evans was unsuccessful at winning the GTS Championship against Kleetus. On April 29, at Paybitch, Evans defeated Bruiser Bonifer, Brandon the Bull and Kleetus to win the GTS Championship. Not long after GTS moved to a warehouse, he threw out the old GTS title to purchase a new one.

After Salami won the YouTube Wrestling Figures Heavyweight Championship from Grim in a Dumpster Match, the 'Cringe Key' (as Grim called him at the time) ran into the ring and cashed in his Food In The Fridge Briefcase and beat Salami for his second YouTube Wrestling Figures Heavyweight Championship. Jay then turned face and he now respects Grim and wants to a have a brotherly battle with him for the Youtube Wrestling Figures Heavyweight Championship. On June 22, Evans successfully retained the Youtube Wrestling Figures Heavyweight Championship against Grim thanks to accidental interference from Controversy. However, the full match was never seen due to Jimmy forgetting to record. On June 26th the 'Cringe Key' successfully defended the Youtube Title against Matt Castle and Ulfric Strongclaw, but only to have to defend his title again against Grim. He defeated Grim after a intentional distraction from Heel Wife and Doom Crew. Evans also hinted a face turn after mouthing the words "Eat it Yeah!" in the outro, but it was unknown if this is a ruse or true.

2 days later, Evans indeed turned face after doing the "Eat it Yeah!" crotch chop and challenging indy wrestler TJ Marconi after TJ attacked him at SWF the day before. The day before Giant Sack of Heat, Marconi appeared at the warehouse and Jay bravely challenged him and put his Youtube title on the line. However, he was badly beaten. At GSOH, he participated in the YouTube title battle royal and was eliminated by Grim. At GTS Suckaslam, Evans participated in a Fatal 4-Way match against Castle, Max Frost, and Joe Wolf for the Million Dollar Championship which was ultimately won by Wolf. At No Money, Evans put his GTS career on the line against Wolf's US Title in a winning effort (similar to how Dolph Ziggler defeated The Miz for the WWE Intercontinental Championship at No Mercy 2016). Not long after losing the belt, Jay stormed out of the GTS warehouse, showing signs of a heel turn after Grim shook hands with Pete Corvus after telling him not to do so. On December 31, 2017, the 'Cringe Key' turned heel on Grim by joining forces with Wolf after hitting a Superkick on Grim. On October 6, 2018, he helped Grim defeat Slenderdick. He, appeared as Ice Demon, again saved GTS by defeating Slenderdick in a casket match. On December 28, 2018, he became Loser Belt Loser after he was superkicked and pinned by his partner Jake Cage. In 2019, he joined Kurt Bale's alliance of AWE, and once AWE was absorbed into GTS, he aligned with Wolf and Cage as Legendary, with Grim turning heel and joining later on. Then, he took some time away from GTS before capturing the YouTube title for a third time!

On October 2nd, 2021, Evans once again turned heel by attacking Grim and saying 'It's not Jay 'The Key' Evans anymore, it's the 'Mar-Key' Jay Evans.' He returned on March 19th, 2022, and went back to using the 'Ice Demon' gimmick.

He was really close to winning the 2022 Superpop Memorial Battle Royal, but bounced back by defeating Issac Scythe in a 'Ice Demon vs TikTok Terrifier' match at Grimamania. He was released shortly after. Evans returned later that year in a winning effort against Ron Voyage.

Conclusion

Just a little piece of advice: don't get in the way of Jay 'The Key' Evans, or the 'Key' will come for you.

In Wrestling

  • Finishing Moves
    • Jay's Way (Reverse STO) (2016-2017)
    • Black Mass (Spinning Heel Kick) Parodied from Aleister Black
    • Jay's Way V2 (Leaping Reverse STO) Parodied from Shelton Benjamin (2017-present)
    • Coup De Grace (Diving Sit-out Double Foot Stomp) (As the Ice Demon) Parodied from Finn Balor
  • Signature Moves
    • Diving knee drop (Parodied from Harley Race sometimes Parodied as Ric Flair's move)
    • Key Crusher (Fisherman Driver)
    • Falcon Arrow, often after a superplex
    • Panama Sunrise (Second-Rope Diving Sunset Flip Piledriver) Parodied from Adam Cole
    • Reversed Corner Splash
    • The Three (Cringe) Keys (Triple Vertical Suplex, often followed with a Russian leg sweep)
    • Snap Suplex
    • Dropkick, usually after an Irish Whip
    • Sling Blade (Spinning Sit-out Sleeper Slam) Parodied from Finn Balor, sometimes parodied from Seth Rollins
    • Best In GTS (Somersault Plancha)
    • Springboard Roundhouse Kick
    • Swanton Bomb (High-Angle Senton Bomb, sometimes while slingshotting)
    • Superkick
    • Key to Success (Triple running uppercuts to an opponent in the corner)
  • With Joe Wolf
    • Double-Team Finishing Moves
      • Magic Killer (Aided snap swinging neckbreaker) - Parodied from Luke Gallows & Karl Anderson
  • Nicknames

As Jay Dempsey

  • Ice Demon
  • Pajama Prick
  • Snow Cock

As Jay Evans

  • Legendary
  • Chicken Breast Chest
  • Tiny Hammer
  • The Key (often called 'The Cringe Key' by the roster, mostly Grim)
  • The 'Mar-Key' Jay Evans
  • Twat Waffle
  • Jay-mus
  • The Cringiest Key that You'll Ever See (called by Grim)
  • Spaghetti Arms (called by Grim)
  • Beevus
  • Spring-Bean Bitch

Championships & Accomplishments

United Wrestling Coalition

Superstars Wrestling Federation

Entrance Music

GTS_Wrestling_-_Jay_Dempsey_AKA_"Ice_Demon"_Theme_Song

GTS Wrestling - Jay Dempsey AKA "Ice Demon" Theme Song

Used as Ice Demon/Jay Dempsey

GTS_Wrestling_-_Jay_"The_Key"_Evans_Theme_Song-1

GTS Wrestling - Jay "The Key" Evans Theme Song-1

Current Theme, used as Jay Evans